Part-timer or casual pool for a regular gap? Pricing 12 hours a week both ways

On the pay guide, a Level 2 part-timer looks $4,731 a year cheaper than a casual pool for 12 regular hours. Pay their leave and cover their weeks off and it's $1,747, and three cancelled weekends wipe that out.
On the pay guide, a part-timer on 12 regular weekend hours looks $4,731 a year cheaper than filling those hours from your casual pool. Pay their leave, cover the weeks they're away, and the real saving is $1,747. Cancel three weekends in a year and it's gone.
Short version: for a Level 2 worker on 12 hours a week that run every week, a part-timer beats a casual pool by about $1,747 a year, on any days of the week. If you cancel the hours more than about three weekends a year, the pool wins. Figures use Hospitality Award (MA000009) rates from the first full pay period on or after 1 July 2026 and apply to adult staff. This is general information, not financial or legal advice.
The gap is $6.77 an hour, every hour
Casual percentages in the Hospitality Award already include the 25% loading. So a Level 2 casual, such as a food and beverage attendant grade 2, costs the same $6.77 an hour more than a part-timer whatever day it is.
| When it's worked | Part-time | Casual | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monday to Friday, 7am to 7pm | $27.08 | $33.85 | $6.77 |
| Saturday | $33.85 | $40.62 | $6.77 |
| Sunday | $40.62 | $47.39 | $6.77 |
| Public holiday | $60.93 | $67.70 | $6.77 |
Twelve hours a week, priced for a whole year
Take six hours on Saturday and six on Sunday. It can't be one 12-hour Saturday for a part-timer, because clause 15.2 caps them at 11.5 ordinary hours a day. That week costs $446.82 on part-time and $528.06 from the pool. The $81.24 difference becomes the $4,731 once you multiply by 52 and add 12% super.
A part-timer doesn't work 52 weeks, though. Pro rata, they accrue 48 hours of annual leave and 24 hours of sick and carer's leave a year, both paid at base rate with no weekend penalty, and annual leave carries a 17.5% loading. While they're away, your pool still works the shifts.
| Annual cost, Level 2 | Part-timer | Casual pool |
|---|---|---|
| Shifts worked | $20,553.72 (46 weeks) | $27,459.12 (52 weeks) |
| Annual leave, 48 hours | $1,299.84 | $0 |
| Leave loading, 17.5% | $227.47 | $0 |
| Sick and carer's leave, 24 hours | $649.92 | $0 |
| Casuals covering 6 weeks away | $3,168.36 | Already counted |
| Super at 12% | $3,107.92 | $3,295.09 |
| Total for the year | $29,007.23 | $30,754.21 |
That assumes the part-timer uses every hour of both entitlements, which is the cautious case. If they take no sick leave, the saving rises to about $2,657. Workers compensation and payroll tax sit on top of both columns and scale with wages, so they barely move the answer. Long service leave isn't counted.
Now the odd part. Run the same 12 hours as weekday daytime shifts and both totals fall, to $21,910.10 and $23,657.09, but the saving is still $1,747. The $6.77 gap is the same every day and leave is paid at base rate either way, so the day drops out. Only the level moves it: about $1,706 at Level 1 and $2,019 at Level 5.
Where the part-timer costs you more
A part-timer's hours are agreed in writing and have to be provided and paid (clause 10.4). A casual's aren't, and that flips the numbers on a bad week. Here's a six-hour Saturday going wrong.
| What happens | Part-timer | Casual |
|---|---|---|
| Called off before they attend, under 7 days' notice | $203.10 | $0 under the award |
| Sent home on arrival | $203.10 | $81.24 (2-hour minimum) |
| Stays one hour past the rostered finish | $54.16 for the hour | $40.62 for the hour |
| Public holiday, venue closes | Base rate for ordinary hours | $0 |
Each whole weekend you call off before anyone attends moves $591.43 towards the pool, because the casual bill disappears while the part-timer's stays. Three of those and the saving is gone. Public holidays only hurt if you close: NSW has five on a Saturday or Sunday in 2027, and if you trade them the gap stays $6.77.
Which one fits your gap
| Your gap looks like | Better fit | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Same days, trades every week | Part-timer | About $1,747 a year cheaper, and the same person each week |
| Called off three or more weekends a year | Casual pool | A shift called off before anyone attends costs nothing |
| Moves with the season or the bookings | Casual pool | Changing a part-timer's agreed hours needs their written consent (clause 10.5) |
| One casual has held it for months | Talk to them | They may be able to give notice to go permanent |
The pool doesn't go away either way. Someone still has to fill those six weeks, so a part-timer drops your fill-ins from 104 shifts a year to 12, and that's the saving no pay guide prints. When one of those 12 drops out on the day, you want names ready.
- Pull the last 12 weeks of timesheets for the gap and count the weekends it really ran.
- Multiply the cancellations up to a year and compare them with three.
- If it holds, put the agreed hours and availability in writing before the first shift, as clause 10.4 requires.
- Keep two or three casuals current for the weeks your part-timer is away.
Fill the gap from the roster
Whichever way you go, the job is the same: a name on every shift and a cost you can check. Shiftly gives you free rostering and award-aware timesheets, with a calculation tool that helps estimate each shift's cost, and you stay responsible for verifying it. When your own casuals can't cover a weekend, the on-demand network built into the roster lets you post the shift to independent contractors along the east coast of Australia. That's the roster that fills itself. Get started with Shiftly.
Frequently asked questions
Is a part-timer cheaper than a casual in hospitality?
On regular hours, yes, but by less than the 25% loading suggests. At Level 2 on 12 hours a week, the saving is about $1,747 a year after leave, loading, cover and super, assuming all leave is taken and the hours run every week.
Do casuals get paid if a shift is cancelled?
Under clause 11.3, a casual must be paid at least 2 consecutive hours each time they're required to attend work, so sending one home on arrival costs $81.24 on a Level 2 Saturday. The award has no payment for a shift called off before they attend, but check the employment contract, which can give more.
Can a casual who works the same shifts every week ask to go permanent?
Yes, if they believe they no longer meet the definition of a casual and have been employed for at least 6 months, or 12 months at a small business. They give written notice under the employee choice pathway, and you can only refuse for certain reasons, so a pool of one person may not stay a pool.
Co-founder of Shiftly. Milan works with hospitality businesses across Australia to make rostering, timesheets and award-based pay radically simpler.


